Chasing the Boogeyman

Starred review from June 18, 2021

This brilliant work of metafiction crafts a not-so-true crime story that feels ripe for a Netflix series. It's 2019, and the Boogeyman has been found, which solves a string of murders that shook a small Maryland town in the '80s. It was a story told by Richard Chizmar (this novel's main character, who shares the author's name), in his 1990s book (which shares this novel's title, Chasing the Boogeyman); the 1990s novel recounts Richard's personal recollections of the events when he was a college graduate returning home. The young Richard is an eyewitness to the growing horror, but he soon finds himself in the Boogeyman's sights. Chizmar's new novel isn't just a clever riff on genre; it's a meditation on the dangers and darkness of home, on what happens when the place where we grew up finally grows up itself--or at least when it discovers the violence it's capable of. Chizmar's novel is a meticulously remembered, beautifully crafted hometown nightmare that reminds readers that nostalgia cuts both ways; sure, it can keep our past alive, but it can also be the shadow man standing at the foot of your bed. VERDICT For true crime and horror fans, this one's essential.--Cody Daigle-Orians, Hartford, CT

Copyright 2021 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

July 1, 2021
Best-selling horror author Chizmar takes creepy to a whole new level with this ""true crime novel,"" set in his small hometown in the summer of 1988, as teenage girls are abducted and murdered in the months between his graduation from college and his January wedding. Every detail about his life, his inner struggle moving from childhood into manhood, marriage, and a career is real, but the murderous reign of terror he documents alongside newspaper reports and even photos--none of it happened. Framed as the reprint of a forgotten publication from 1990 with a 2019 update, the volume is a solid true crime facsimile, mixing background detail with action, suspense, and a compelling pace. As metafiction, the book excels: the proximity to reality adds an unshakable level of unease, and it is injected with just the right amount of self-reflection to forge an ironically honest, emotional connection with the reader. The result is strikingly original, a story that will thrill fans of intimately investigated nonfiction like Michelle McNamara's I'll Be Gone in the Dark (2018) and self-aware, psychological suspense like Oyinkan Braithwaite's My Sister, the Serial Killer (2018).

COPYRIGHT(2021) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

September 27, 2021
This impressive metafictional thriller from bestseller Chizmar (Widow’s Point) mixes autobiography with crime. In the summer of 1988, with a freshly minted journalism degree, a version of Chizmar’s younger self returns to his small, idyllic hometown of Edgewood, Md., to live with his parents for seven months until his marriage. During that time, four teenage girls with whom Chizmar has some connection (“They were friends of friends, siblings of friends, or in some cases, children of friends”) are murdered. In between writing horror stories and preparing the debut issue of his horror and suspense magazine, Cemetery Dance, Chizmar gets involved in the hunt for the killer. A hopscotch grid with mystifying numbers in the squares may be an important clue. Authentic-looking photos at the end of each chapter of such people as victims, police personnel, and ordinary residents of Edgewood reinforce the true crime conceit. Though the solution is somewhat obvious, getting to it takes the reader on a smart, entertaining ride. Chizmar should win new fans with this unusual tale. Agent: Kristin Nelson, Nelson Literary.